Low-budget western, starring Angus Macfadyen as the notorious saloon owner, Will Tunney, who shatters the childhood innocence of James Conners (Justin Ament) when he murders the boy's father, played by William Sadler. 15 years on, Conners returns to his hometown of Legend, New Mexico to avenge his father's death and to renew his relationship with long-lost love Mary (Marnie Alton). He soon discovers Tunney to be an even more forceful opponent when Tunney defeats him and leaves him to die. After rescuing Connors, two Native Americans, Washakie (Michael Spears) and Miakoda (Tonantzin Carmelo), encourage him to not seek revenge and instead, reflect within himself to let go of the past.

Jigsaw (Tobin Bell) returns in this gore-soaked sequel. After eluding the cops, psychopathic killer Jigsaw turns an abandoned warehouse on the edge of town into a gruesome torture chamber. Jigsaw's new protegee Amanda (Shawnee Smith) kidnaps a doctor who's forced to keep the evil master alive. Barely clinging to life, Jigsaw begins to carry out his gruesome plans for the doctor and another helpless victim.